Evolutions in languages can give a false sense of differentness in writers of previous ages
September 8, 2021 • 2 min
From Life and Writings of Sir Thomas More, page n21
One singular result is inevitable from this method of presenting my materials.
More wrote both in Latin and in English. The English in the early part of the sixteenth century has become antiquated, and thus presents a great contrast with the translations from Latin into modern English.
More will, therefore, be found speaking, as it were, two languages, or two very different dialects of the same language—that of the first years of the sixteenth century, and that of the last years of the nineteenth.
If this is anomalous, it may serve to bring home to us an important fact. What we call the quaint words and turns of old English make us regard the writers or speakers of that language as themselves quaint, strange, uncouth, rude, simple, or in some way unlike men and women of the same class of society, the same talents and education at the present day.
But if they wrote in Latin, the delusion—for such it is—is dissipated.
Latin is to us what it was to them. It has not become antiquated or changed its form. We find that they wrote just as we should write, if we were as well versed in the language as they were.
They thought just as we think. We turn their words into our modern English, and all quaintness has disappeared. There is nothing odd or unusual in their way of reasoning or in their modes of feeling.
As soon as they speak our own language in our own form or dialect, we judge of them for good or evil as we judge of our contemporaries; and we cease to patronise them, as if they were only clever boys or promising savages.
Latest book snippets
See all 274 | Random Book Snippet
-
September 19, 2021
-
Patiently enduring Crosses while praying God remove them
5 min — Wisdom and Wit of Blessed Thomas More
-
-
September 18, 2021
-
True devotion is never incompatible with our state of life, but enriches it
1 min — Introduction to the Devout Life -
St. Thomas More predicting the destruction of society when it rejects truth and morals
2 min — Life and Writings of Sir Thomas More
-
-
September 17, 2021
-
The Writings of some Saints on the Heavenly Glory of Mary
2 min — The Glories of Mary -
The trap of falsely pious desires, and how to avoid it
4 min — The Spiritual Combat -
St. Joseph was a far more perfect father to Jesus than natural fathers are
3 min — The Life and Glories of St. Joseph -
Devotion should be practiced differently in each vocation
1 min — Introduction to the Devout Life
-
